Tuesday, March 4, 2014

Unlocking A Deadlock

On February 15th, 2014, news reports announced that a panel of Florida jurors found Michael Dunn guilty on three charges of attempted second-degree murder, and one count of firing a weapon into a vehicle.  These charges stemmed from a November 2012 altercation over loud music between Dunn and four teenagers at a local Jacksonville convenience store that left seventeen year-old Jordan Davis dead.  During the verbal exchange, Dunn saw what he believed to be a weapon.  He brandished a handgun from his car’s glove compartment and fired ten shots, nine of which hit the vehicle containing Tevin Thompson, Leland Brunson, Tommy Stornes, and Jordan Davis.  Of the nine shots that hit the car, three hit Davis.  Officers later discovered that the teenagers were unarmed.


A conviction for these four charges means that Michael Dunn could face several decades in prison.  Prosecutor Erin Wolfson stated that each attempted second degree murder conviction carries with it a minimum sentence of twenty years and a possible fifteen-year sentence for shooting into the vehicle, totaling seventy-five years.  Despite a conviction on these counts, the seven women and five men jury were unable to reach a verdict on this case’s most serious charge— first-degree murder.  After deliberating for an excess of thirty hours, spread over the course of four days, the jury was unable to reach a consensus, and the judge declared a mistrial on the first-degree murder charge.  Days later, Valerie, juror #4, explained that during deliberations eight jurors felt that Dunn was unjustified in killing Davis.  Of the remaining four jurors, two felt that he was justified, and two were unsure.

Michael Dunn will be sentenced on March 24th.  Florida State Attorney Angela Corey plans to retry Dunn on the first-degree murder charge.  Cases such as this, and instances of an impasse among jurors call for an examination of deadlock jury procedure.

Chapter 24 of LeFave & Scott’s Criminal Procedure guideline addresses issues relating to deadlocked juries.  After the jury has been deliberating for some time, the jury may report to the judge that it has been unable to reach a decision.  Judges may also encourage a deadlocked jury to reach a verdict through a form of instruction called an “Allen Charge” or “dynamite charge”.  The term dynamite charge was coined because of the instruction’s ability to blow apart a deadlock.  With the exception of a few state statutes that restrict the number of times a judge may order jurors to renew deliberations, judges may send jurors back to deliberate several times.

The Allen charge was birthed in the 1896 case, Allen v. United States.  In Allen, the Court ruled that a judge had the right to strongly encourage a deadlocked jury to continue deliberating until a verdict was reached.  Today, several variations of the Allen Charge are used in courts throughout the nation.  In giving the Allen Charge, a judge must take care to not make the supplemental instruction impermissibly coercive.

Deadlocked juries present a discouraging dilemma to trial judges and counsel hoping to avert costly retrials and avoid bogging down in a quagmire of drawn-out deliberations.  The primary danger jury deadlock poses for the unwary trial judge is the possibility of reversal on appeal due to the perception of court coercion.”

To ensure that this does not happen, a trial judge must avoid any appearance of an attempt to lead the jury to believe that they are required to reach a verdict.

In an effort to prevent jury coercion by trial judges, the Florida Supreme Court drafted a version of the Allen charge that “allows a jury to continue deliberations, even after it has announced its inability to do so, where there is a reasonable basis to believe a verdict is possible, while cautioning jurors that they should not abandon their views just to get a verdict or to accommodate the majority.  The text of Florida’s Allen Charge, which was first approved in State v. Bryan, 290 So. 2d 482 (Fla. 1974), reads as follows:

“I know that all of you have worked hard to try to find a verdict in this case. It apparently has been impossible for you so far. Sometimes an early vote before discussion can make it hard to reach an agreement about the case later. The vote, not the discussion, might make it hard to see all sides of the case. We are all aware that it is legally permissible for a jury to disagree. There are two things a jury can lawfully do: agree on a verdict or disagree on what the facts of the case may truly be. There is nothing to disagree about on the law. The law is as I told you. If you have any disagreements about the law, I should clear them for you now. That should be my problem, not yours. If you disagree over what you believe the evidence showed, then only you can resolve that conflict, if it is to be resolved. I have only one request of you. By law, I cannot demand this of you, but I want you to go back into the jury room. Then, taking turns, tell each of the other jurors about any weakness of your own position. You should not interrupt each other or comment on each other's views until each of you had a chance to talk. After you have done that, if you simply cannot reach a verdict, then return to the courtroom and I will declare this case mistried, and will discharge you with my sincere appreciation of your services. You may now retire to continue with your deliberations.”


Currently, Florida’s deadlock jury procedure dictates that once a jury informs the court that it is deadlocked, the trial judge should either declare a mistrial or read the Allen charge of Standard Jury Instruction 3.06.

Deadlocked juries are a quandary that elicited the following words of Brazilian diplomat and Director-General of the World Trade Organization, Roberto Azevêdo: “Each blockage is a blockage.  Each impasse is an impasse.  You have to find a solution; there is no recipe that fits each one of them.”  An Allen charge to deadlocked juries can be a resolution in some cases, but cannot be the end all solution that fits every case.  It seems that by declaring a mistrial on Michael Dunn’s first-degree murder charge, Judge Russell Healey enacted a solution that was within the bounds of Florida’s deadlock instruction framework.  Had Judge Healey decided to not declare a mistrial and prompted the jurors to continue deliberating, the ultimate outcome may have been similar to the 1999 Florida case of Thomas v. Statewhere the Supreme Court found reversible error due to an improper influence of the jury’s verdict.

For practitioners, deadlocked juries, mistrials, and ensuing retrials are financially taxing and place a strain on judicial resources.  However, jury research suggests that practitioners can take certain measures to reduce the likelihood of a deadlock occurring.  Kalven and Zeisel’s research findings suggest that “deadlocked juries occur more often in deliberations that begin with verdict driven approaches instead of evidence driven approaches; deadlock juries typically give much weaker rating to the power of the evidence and the clarity of the law than unanimous juries; and deadlocked juries are more likely to occur when there was one person in the group who refused to move off of their initial, and often weak position.”  With this information in mind, it would seem that practitioners would best be able to circumvent a deadlock by placing an over-and-above emphasis on the evidence consideration in their opening and closing statements.

          
Stephane L. Plantin
Staffer, Criminal Law Practitioner



Image by Dori (Own work), via Wikimedia Commons.




20 comments:

  1. It is not necessary to remove the paper or governmental procedures on loans of 3 month loans, because the application process and evaluation will be conducted online to place. The method of applying these loans is very simple and suitable, because it is done online and do not require certification or fax any papers. Borrower must complete an online application in which he / she must complete offer personal information such as age, name, address, monthly income. Once the method of confirmation is complete, the lender approves the loan and the amount is transferred to the account of the borrower within 24 hours. Lenders confirm the form and if it is fulfilled approve the request. This helps the borrowers get money quickly, without hassle and without stress. small loans are one of the best ways of acquiring cash in an emergency.

    In difficult times, we need to look 3 months loans online in order to get decent means many urgent financial problems in time to manage. These loans provide money to employees in the middle of the month when usually emergency occurs and people are still waiting for their next paycheck. The best part of 3 month payday loans online is that it does not control the plant. This means that there is no problem when a person with bad credit applies labels for these loans. 3 months cash loans online provides quick and easy, and this amount can be used for many unexpected financial needs and desires like paying college expenses, medical expenses, credit card, be used at home, leasing, auto repair, etc.
    http://www.3monthloansnow.co.uk/
    http://p-loansinuk.co.uk/small-loans.html

    ReplyDelete
  2. To complete the Entire process of same day loans , you need to fill up online application form with your full details: such as name, gender, age and bank account etc. After credit verification, you will get instant same day personal loans approval within 24 hours. Malthus, payday cash loans you will be getting the sum of loan amount on the same day with ease
    http://www.personalloanssameday.co.uk/ .

    ReplyDelete
  3. Another kind of quick loans is available called the Quick Pay Day instant cash loans. This loan is issued on a short term basis, sometimes sanctioned in a day. They also allow a very small range of amount issued, up to 1000 pounds only. 6 month loans They charge a very high rate of interest as Compared to the above two. http://www.quickloans6month.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  4. The method is quite simple work of money . The amount of 6 month payday loans normally ranges from around, and the lenders Usually charge a one-time fee based on A Certain percentage of the money borrowed . 3 month payday loans Regularly this money is to be paid back to the lender within 30 days, or about the time the next income comes around . Some person need very Quickly , Regularly inside 24 hours or a smaller amount

    http://www.3-6monthpaydayloans.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  5. These
    loans for people on benefit let you be able to take care of your family and kids by providing you ready funds quickly. With the help of this fiscal backing you can meet your various needs without making any delay and you can utilize the borrowed sum for some urgent situations Concerning the loans for people on benefits medical bills, utility bills, grocery bills, maintenance of your property or for repairing or servicing 'may be of your car. http://ukloansforpeopleonbenefitss.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  6. Bad credit holders share the same needs and desires as others. But unfortunately, due to poor credit status in the Their MARKET, thesis people face a lot of difficulty in getting financial help. long term loans no guarantor This financial assistance is very important for people as it helps to fulfill one's financial needs and requirements. long term loans Long term loans is a financial scheme Which helps borrowers seeking to avail cash without any troubles as this kind of financial scheme does not require credit checks. http://longtermloansc.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  7. Middle online application is devoid of fax and paperwork prolonged. This is the purpose that 'there is no need to worry about Organize documents to fax. Running on complications Including default bad credit, arrears, foreclosure, skipping of installments, bankruptcy, payments, missed payments, etc., are invited to benefit from payday loans no brokers payday loans without going through any difficulty.

    payday loans no fees
    online payday loans
    payday loans for bad credit

    ReplyDelete
  8. These are the easiest, most convenient and fastest mode of instant cash loans. The Payday loans Australia is famous for the reliability and quick services. This easy payday loans are the types of loans in the loan application Which, approval and payment procedure is fully online. Ran thus, it saves time, MONEY and energy of the borrowers. Many reputed FINANCIAL organization in Australia Provide the payday easy loans to the lenders under many urgent situations. The application procedure is very fast and easy without any lengthy formalities. The loan payback process is so very simple. http://www.3monthpaydayloans-6.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  9. At the time of application for the online payday loans.
    The benefits There are huge benefits and advantages available from this scheme. The primary advantage is the easy and quick availability of cash loan under difficult situation. easy payday loans The other benefit is the debiting of the loan amount by the organization Itself. Ran thus, the borrower need not have to rush to the office of the lender for getting and paying back the
    easy loans. The whole process of it is genuine and highly reliable. http://www.3monthpaydayloans-6.co.uk/


    ReplyDelete
  10. So, you do not need to use lengthy formality, paperwork or faxing of documents. This takes few minutes and hassle-free to get APPLIED for the payday loans for bad credit. Even if you are tagged with bad credit records any, you have the option to get rightful seeking 6 month loans since there is no involvement of credit checks. More-over, seeking 3 month payday loans can be of proving without pledging of collateral too. http://www.paydayloans3month6.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Lenders of synthesis long term loans can Provide up to five thousand pounds of new customers, or mark rate at about 50 percent. Of course, high street banks and long term loans no guarantor are quiet more than fifty percent of high, but high street banks and lenders are very strict standards, They Do not tend to lend to people missed payments, Guarantor lender can offer loan terms up to five years, making monthly payments more expensive, give the opportunity to Applicanthttp://longtermloansc.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  12. For All Those people who are council tenant, private tenant, home tenant or living with friends can therefore fetch the FINANCIAL support through guaranteed bad credit easy loans in hassle-free approach. These are short term and unsecured in nature and so the rate of interest charged is somewhat higher in comparison of other easy payday loans. On the other hand you can acquire the best finance DEAL with synthesis loans but you have to make a systematic research for the best online lender of payday lenders miscellaneous UK. http://www.3monthpaydayloans-6.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  13. For All Those people who are council tenant, private tenant, home tenant or living with friends can therefore fetch the FINANCIAL support through guaranteed bad credit easy loans in hassle-free approach. These are short term and unsecured in nature and so the rate of interest charged is somewhat higher in comparison of other easy payday loans. On the other hand you can acquire the best finance DEAL with synthesis loans but you have to make a systematic research for the best online lender of payday lenders miscellaneous UK. http://www.3monthpaydayloans-6.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  14. There is not any strict rule under the category of 6 month loans did compel you to get limited cash. DEPENDING on your repayment ability lender offers you cash. payday loans for bad credit Here what is suggestive is did you can be liable to return the amount within 12 months without Encountering any unwanted state of affairs. 3 month payday loans Under this scheme, to individual is OFFERED cash in advance at the promise made in between borrower and lender did the former wants to repay the amount within the specific Offered period of time. HOWEVER, what is more entertaining is did the lender can extend the days of repayment. http://www.paydayloans3month6.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  15. There are times When loans do not come your way for the sheer factthat loans require the borrower to meet Certain pre-conditions. One of them did feature undoubtedly, in most cases loan sanction is did of having a good credit score. long term loans no guarantor Not posse sing that can be a serious cause for worry. What remains is the fact that bad creditors are left financially unaided as a result by loan lenders. Such a circumstance can be Avoided through long term loans for bad credit. These long term loans are more than just fiscal aid. They are a gift of replenishment did the lenders of long term loans for bad credit Provide. http://longtermloansc.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  16. This repayment schedule can be extended by paying scant fee to the providers of synthesis finances. Same day loans for people on benefits for people on benefits are crafted to eradicate all small term unforeseen expenses, like paying off medical bills, hospital bills, grocery store bills, traveling expenses, home rent, credit card dues and many more. loans for people on benefit Interest rates levied on this amount are a bit high but a systematic research online can help you to fetch at affordable interest rate. http://ukloansforpeopleonbenefitss.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  17. ICC Mortgage And financial Services,Is a sincere and certified private Loan company approved by the Government,we give out international and local loans to all countries in the world,Amount given out $2,500 to $100,000,000
    Dollars, Euro and Pounds.We offer loans with a dependable guarantee to all of our clients. Our loan interest rates are very low and affordable with a negotiable duration.
    Available now
    MORTGAGE, PERSONAL, TRAVEL, STUDENT, EXPANSION OF BUSINESS AND NEW UNSECURED, SECURE, CONSOLIDATE
    AND MORE
    Available now..
    Apply for a loan today with your loan amount and duration, Its Easy and fast to get. 4% interest rates and monthly
    installment payments.
    {nicholasbrush.icc@gmail.com}

    Regards,
    Nicholas Brush

    ReplyDelete
  18. Some want students abroad so that to have them, pay the high fees and costs of the hostel. quick loans no credit check Sometimes areas are so urgent that we have to organize the money in no time. So we want a quick help. quickly Student loans are provided by lenders available to solve the financial problems in a short time. What do you do when you really need money immediately? for quick loans birth, for example, your wife, your child wants a stylish birthday gift, or your mother is in the hospital. The fastest solution to all problems is the loan. Your job may not offer adequate compensation to meet all your needs and content usually seems so far away, when the capital requirement Immediately.
    http://www.quickloansx.co.uk/
    http://samedayloansukonline.blogspot.in/2014/09/quick-loans-in-15-minutes-beneficial.html

    ReplyDelete
  19. Did you know that that you can make cash by locking selected sections of your blog or website?
    To start just join AdWorkMedia and use their Content Locking tool.

    ReplyDelete
  20. natural infobtech

    chiru khidi no 150 https://youtu.be/ewxbC0CyZHI

    ReplyDelete